From Teaching to Leading: How to Transition into Academic Administration (the Right Way)

By Dr. Dani Babb, Founder of Faculty Job Tools and Babb Education

Moving from a faculty role into administration isn’t just a step up — it’s a leap into a different world of responsibilities, language, and leadership expectations. Like most of my blog articles, this is written so you can completely do it yourself or hire us to help you!

You’ve taught, mentored, and published. You’ve helped students succeed and worked collaboratively with colleagues. You might have even coordinated a program, led a curriculum refresh, or managed adjuncts.

But when you apply for administrative roles — department chair, program director, assistant dean, associate provost — and you’re still using a faculty CV, the message you send is this: “I want the job, but I haven’t stepped into it yet.”

That’s where most qualified faculty get stuck.

After working on hundreds of these transitions and consulting with hiring deans and provosts, I can tell you: the faculty-to-leader shift isn’t just about applying — it’s about rebranding your experience to match what institutions are actually hiring for.

Why Most Administrative Applications Fall Flat

Let’s start with the most common reasons otherwise excellent candidates never hear back:

• Their CV reads like a teaching résumé, not an operational leadership document.
• The language in their cover letter is focused on students and pedagogy instead of strategic goals and outcomes.
• They underestimate how competitive these roles are — many are internal searches or invitation-based.
• They have no clear, demonstrated experience with compliance, conflict resolution, curriculum oversight, data-driven decision-making, or team leadership.

Most applicants are only one well-written document away from being taken seriously. But that document has to tell the right story.

What Hiring Committees Are Really Looking For

The jump from the classroom to the administrative office isn’t about your course evaluations anymore. Here’s what deans and provosts look for when hiring for leadership roles:

• Strategic Thinking: Have you demonstrated the ability to align academic programs with institutional goals?
• Oversight & Operational Experience: Have you supervised faculty, managed budgets, dealt with scheduling, or handled course rotations?
• Accreditation & Compliance Awareness: Can you speak the language of regional accrediting bodies or internal policy governance?
• Oversight & Operational Experience: Have you supervised faculty, managed budgets, dealt with scheduling, or handled course rotations?
• Conflict Resolution: Have you resolved disputes, addressed student complaints, or mediated peer-to-peer issues?
• Initiative: Have you led committees, launched programs, or initiated change at your institution?

They aren’t just looking for a good teacher with “leadership potential.” They’re hiring someone who can manage people, solve problems, and execute strategy — often under pressure and political complexity.

Step 1: Rewriting Your CV for Administration

Let’s be clear: your current CV, no matter how polished, was likely written to land teaching positions. It’s time to evolve it.

Remove:

• Long lists of courses taught with course numbers
• Bulleted responsibilities that read like a job description
• Outdated sections like “Educator Attributes” or philosophy that only speaks to classroom goals
• eaching-focused outcomes (like student engagement tools) without context for leadership roles

Add:

• Administrative achievements (even informal ones) — think: led faculty committees, coordinated accreditation responses, managed adjunct faculty
• Key phrases aligned with leadership: academic operations, student retention, budgeting, policy compliance, conflict resolution, institutional effectiveness
• Clear sections for:
• Leadership Experience
• Program Oversight
• Strategic Initiatives
• Faculty Supervision
• Instructional Design & Curriculum Development

A 2026-ready CV for administration is narrative-driven, impact-oriented, and operational in tone. It’s not just “here’s what I did,” but “here’s the institutional value I added.”

Step 2: Retooling Your Cover Letter

Most applicants still write cover letters that focus on teaching, student relationships, or their love of higher education. That’s not enough.

Your cover letter should:

• Be addressed to a specific dean, chair, or provost (and yes, we write those for our clients at Faculty Job Tools)
• Open with a clear statement of leadership philosophy, not teaching philosophy
• Tie your background to institutional strategy, accreditation cycles, enrollment pressures, or retention goals
• Include measurable accomplishments, even if they’re soft data (e.g., improved adjunct onboarding, reduced student complaints, implemented conflict resolution model)

Hiring committees want to see that you understand the bigger picture. Your cover letter is the place to show it.

Step 3: Bridging Your Teaching Background to Leadership

This is where most faculty struggle. You’ve been teaching for years — but how do you make that feel like administrative experience?

We help our clients translate these line by line, paragraph by paragraph — so that hiring committees see you as a peer, not just a classroom instructor trying to “move up.”

Step 4: Choosing the Right Roles to Apply For

Not every admin job is the right fit for every faculty candidate. At Faculty Job Tools, we help clients assess:

• Is this a full administrative role or hybrid (e.g., 50% teaching, 50% ops)?
• Is it centralized administration or department-based?
• What’s the leadership structure and span of control?
• Is this the right first step, or should you apply for an interim, assistant, or internal coordinator role first?

We often guide faculty toward roles like:

• Assistant/Associate Chair
• Program Director
• Online Division Coordinator
• Faculty Development Lead
• Instructional Quality Reviewer
• Director of Curriculum and Instruction

Many of these positions are stepping stones to dean, provost, or VPAA — and they require a strategy just like full-time roles do.

Step 5: Reaching Out Strategically

One of the most underused — but most effective — tactics in transitioning into academic leadership is intentional outreach.

That’s why we help clients:

• Craft custom messages to send to hiring deans and chairs at institutions of their choice
• Position themselves for future openings before they go live
• Build credibility through thoughtful introduction emails, especially for leadership-track roles

You don’t need to wait for a job posting to appear. At the leadership level, many positions are filled internally or by invitation. You can — and should — start that conversation first.

Step 6: Targeting the Right Institutions

You may be leadership-ready — but are you applying where you’re most likely to be hired?

At Faculty Job Tools, we evaluate the hiring patterns, academic models, and leadership needs of:

• Private nonprofit universities
• Regional comprehensives
• Faith-based institutions
• Online and adult-focused colleges
• Community colleges expanding online leadership

We also research what their programs look like, how fast they’re growing, and which departments are seeing turnover.

That’s how we build your custom job search — not with guesswork or job alerts, but real data.

Step 7: Letting Us Apply for You (Yes, Really)

Faculty clients are busy. That’s why we don’t just give you leads — we can apply on your behalf.

Here’s how it works:

• You tell us your goals, parameters, availability, and preferences.
• We search for matches (including roles you won’t find on major boards).
• We revise your CV, write custom letters, and tailor every application.
• We apply — for you.

We also send follow-up messages to deans and provosts when appropriate, increasing your visibility even before interviews.

For those transitioning into leadership, this support is often the difference between staying stuck in the classroom and moving into a role with impact.

Why Faculty Job Tools Is Built for This

We aren’t a resume factory or AI-driven job scraper.

We’re a team of real people who work in higher education, many of whom have chaired hiring committees, served in academic administration, and designed curriculum for national online universities.

We’ve helped thousands of faculty get hired — and increasingly, we’re helping them step into leadership.

If that’s your next move, let us help you do it right.

Ready to Move into Administration?

Let’s get to work: https://facultyjobtools.com/

---